Showing posts with label Gilad Shalit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gilad Shalit. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 29, 2011

What Gilad Missed

A few days ago, I posted Gilad Shalit 5 Years in Captivity. I mentioned in the post that I shared the presentation with several friends that led Birthright trips. My friend Elissa B, was the first person to use the presentation on a Birthright trip (we lead trips at the same time, she used it before I did), and gave me very encouraging and appreciated feedback.

Elissa happens to also be one of if not the biggest fan of this blog, and in response to my post from earlier in the week, she sent me to the site http://www.whatgiladmissed.org/ and video, which I had not yet seen or would have otherwise included in my post.


The video tries to make people realize the magnitude of five years. While I think that some of the things the video points out that Gilad missed are not such big events (Lady Gaga, Royal Wedding, Nintendo Wii, and Brett Farve's career track - although this one has some humor and perspective - he retired three times in 5 years), the reality of 5 years is brought out through the video and is sure to strike a chord with younger, generally more apathetic population. A demographic that needs to be captivated and familiarized with the injustice and horrific treatment Hamas has dealt Gilad Shalit, the Shalit family and Israel as a whole.

Another interesting point I’d like to share while I have the floor and am on the topic relates to a recent condemnation of Hamas by a group of human rights organizations including Amnesty International, human Rights Watch as well as both Israeli and Palestinian. The released statement  condemned Hamas’ illegal treatment of Gilad, for not allowing him to contact his family or be visited by the Red Cross.

While some view this as a huge statement, especially from Palestinian human rights groups, it was terrible to see that the statement did not call for the release of Gilad Shalit – while the organizations want him treated fairly, they did not call for his release. This is a terrible shortcoming. Interestingly, I read an article (I’m sorry I can’t find it), which discussed how Hamas is furious with Palestinian human rights organizations for saying the treatment of Gilad Shalit is inhumane.

In response to Hamas’ continued refusal to abide by international law of prisoner treatment, the Prime Minister announced last week that he was imposing a series of crackdowns on the liberties given to Palestinian prisoners. These include high speed internet access and access to education to receive higher degrees. Just to once again put things in perspective, while Gilad Shalit has been held in isolated captivity for the past five years, a Palestinian could have completed his PhD and would now be afforded the title of doctor upon his release. The injustice is nearly too much to bear.

Thanks again for the link Elissa.

Sunday, June 26, 2011

Gilad Shalit - 5 Years in Captivity

Yesterday marked the fifth anniversary of the capture of Gilad Shalit, a then 19 year old soldier who was abducted by Hamas in an attack on an Israeli outpost through use of a tunnel. For five years, Gilad has been held captive by Hamas who has demanded the release of over 1,000 convicted and suspected terrorists, including some convicted of murder, for Gilad’s release. Everyone in Israel knows the name Gilad Shalit and suffers along with his immediate family, as we all pray for his release.
Israel’s reaction to the terrible situation of having a captive soldier in enemy hands, brings to light the humanity and value of human life that Israel lives by. The fact that negotiations for one soldier are not whether 1,000 terrorists will be released for his freedom, but which terrorists the country can release is a testament to our sanctification of life.
In preparation for my Birthright Israel trip, I prepared a presentation that illustrated the dilemmas and challenges faced by the government and Israeli society with regards to a captive soldier. The presentation was used in what I thought was a very powerful discussion session between our participants and soldiers that joined our group. After presenting the presentation to my group, I shared the presentation with several friends leading Birthright trips. Over the weekend, it dawned on me that these ideas should not be shared only with Birthright participants, but should be discussed by everyone who cares for Israel. As a result, I have uploaded the presentation here and encourage you to page through, read and or share this material with others. This presentation was largely inspired by a speech I listened to by Dr. Daniel Gordis presented at Suburban Orthodox Congregation Toras Chaim (my families synagogue in Baltimore). Dr. Gordis’ speech titled “Not a Moment’s Regret: Reflections of an Unabashed Zionist” is inspiring and a very worthwhile listen.
Please keep Gilad Shalit in your thoughts and prayers, and may we soon celebrate the joyous day of his return to Israel.